Sierra LaMar retrial: School bus driver recalls not seeing teen at normal stop
Published in News & Features
SAN JOSE — Kim Kirkpatrick, a former school bus driver in Morgan Hill, testified Wednesday about how for most of the second week of March 2012, it was a routine sight for 15-year-old Sierra LaMar to hop on her bus headed for Ann Sobrato High School.
But on Friday, March 16, Kirkpatrick did not see Sierra anywhere near her normal pickup spot at Palm and Dougherty avenues, even with the clear sightlines provided by the relatively flat surrounding fields.
Her account was part of the third week of witness testimony in the murder retrial of Antolin Garcia Torres, whose 2017 conviction in the disappearance and presumed death of Sierra was overturned by an appellate court earlier this year.
Kirkpatrick said on the morning in question, she halted the bus for a moment just in case the teen was running late: On occasion, Sierra literally ran down Dougherty to catch the bus.
“It was habit for me,” Kirkpatrick said during court testimony Wednesday. “I didn’t want to miss her.”
Santa Clara County Deputy Alternate Defender Al Lopez followed up: “Is it fair to say you didn’t see her anywhere near the bus stop?”
“I did not see her,” Kirkpatrick replied.
After a brief wait, Kirkpatrick said, she continued her route. The next morning, she said she got an urgent call from her dispatcher asking if she had transported Sierra the day before. In the coming days and weeks, she would join the South County community in wondering what happened to Sierra, who to this day has never been found.
Kirkpatrick recounted that her last memory of Sierra was dropping her off at her stop the afternoon of March 15.
Deputy District Attorney O’Bryan Kenney asked, “Did anything seem out of the ordinary about her?”
“No,” she said.
Kenney’s questions focused on establishing to the jury, through bus surveillance videos, timestamp estimates and schedules, that Sierra’s target pickup time was 7:24 a.m. each weekday morning, but also that the time window stretched as much as 10 minutes in either direction.
Lopez’s cross-examination of Kirkpatrick drew on much of the same information but sought to tighten that range, highlighting that a student pickup a couple of minutes later affirmed the target time was precise. It’s a key element of the defense case, which contends the prosecution has presented an “impossible” timeline for Garcia Torres to have driven from his home eight miles south and caught up with Sierra as she walked to her bus stop.
In opening statements, Lopez noted surveillance video showed Garcia Torres leave in his red Volkswagen Jetta from the Maple Leaf RV Park at 7 a.m., and cited a detective’s estimate that the drive to Sierra’s stop was between 11 and 13 minutes long. He has argued that in light of Sierra’s last known act — a selfie photo taken on her MacBook in her bedroom — occurring at 7:12 a.m., Garcia Torres would have either driven past the bus stop before Sierra ever left her house, or would not have had enough time to grab and force the girl into his car without being seen by her approaching school bus.
Kenney countered by drawing jurors’ attention to the admitted lack of precision in timestamps recorded by bus cameras, through testimony from Kirkpatrick and her supervisor, Kathleen Rael. Their combined accounts described time drifting in the system clocks and how there was no verified log for when a bus stop was reached, and how drivers relied on local landmarks to gauge time and location. Those details bolster Kenney’s position, previewed in his opening statements, that there was a wider berth and ample time and opportunity for Garcia Torres to abduct Sierra without detection.
Earlier Wednesday, Lopez continued his cross-examination of Santa Clara County Sheriff’s Sgt. Brian Randall, who handled and processed the initial evidence gathered following Sierra’s disappearance. That included her cell phone found less than a mile west of her home and school bus stop, and her duffel bag containing the clothing she was believed to have been wearing, recovered in a cactus by a metal shed about two miles away.
Through their questioning of Randall, Lopez and Kenney sparred over the method with which the bag and its contents were processed and photographed. Randall testified how, inside a police trailer serving as a command post, he created an improvised examination table by turning over a dry erase board and laying items on it to photograph them. Among the contents of the bag were a pair of Sierra’s blue jeans that Randall reported smelled of urine and from which reputed incriminating DNA was collected.
Lopez interrogated Randall about why the shed site on Laguna Avenue where the bag was found was not cordoned off for further investigation and examination. Lopez has characterized these circumstances as examples of authorities overlooking potential crime scenes and, by extension, other possible culprits behind what happened to Sierra, whose body has never been found.
Randall consistently defended his actions in part by emphasizing that the work he, other deputies and search-and-rescue volunteers were doing in the immediate days after Sierra vanished was focused on finding her, and that there was no obvious evidence of a crime in those early stages. Kenney challenged Lopez’s questioning by spurring Randall to assert that Garcia Torres had no way to intersect with any of the sites where evidence was examined or processed, suggesting to jurors that the only way for incriminating DNA to be left on the jeans was through contact with Sierra.
Other testimony given so far includes family members’ and other investigators’ recounting of realizing and responding to Sierra being missing. Garcia Torres was convicted of murdering and abducting Sierra and was serving a life-without-parole prison sentence until this past February, when the 6th District Court of Appeal threw out the murder verdict, ruling it was tainted because the trial court consolidated the murder charge with three unrelated attempted kidnapping allegations reported three years before Sierra disappeared.
_____
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at mercurynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments